Padres vs Yankees Prediction: King vs Schmidt Pitching Duel at Yankee Stadium

Streaking Padres Face Struggling Yankees in Bronx Showdown

The San Diego Padres (23-11) look to continue their impressive winning streak as they face the New York Yankees (19-16) in game two of their series at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, May 6, 2025. After staging a dramatic comeback in Monday’s opener, the red-hot Padres send former Yankee Michael King to the mound against his old team, while New York counters with the recently activated Clarke Schmidt.

This interleague matchup features contrasting teams – San Diego riding a six-game winning streak versus New York dropping four of their last five contests. Despite their recent struggles, the Yankees remain atop the AL East, while the surging Padres have climbed to second in the NL West. Let’s break down both sides and identify the best betting value for Tuesday’s contest.

San Diego Padres Analysis: Former Yankee King Returns to the Bronx

Monday’s series opener perfectly encapsulated the Padres’ recent resilience. Trailing 3-0 in the late innings, San Diego exploded for four runs in the eighth to steal a 4-3 victory. Veterans Manny Machado and Xander Bogaerts delivered the crucial blows, each driving in two runs to spark the comeback.

The Padres enter Tuesday’s contest having won six straight, including a weekend sweep of Pittsburgh and taking both games against San Francisco prior to arriving in New York. This hot streak has elevated them to 23-11 overall, placing them firmly in contention in the competitive NL West.

San Diego’s success stems from exceptional pitching, as evidenced by their stellar 2.73 team ERA, 1.14 WHIP, and .211 opponent batting average – all among the league’s best marks. The offense has been effective though not overwhelming, producing 137 runs with a respectable .257 team batting average and .327 on-base percentage.

Michael King (4-1, 2.09 ERA, 1.01 WHIP) takes the ball Tuesday in what represents a significant homecoming. The right-hander, acquired from New York in the Juan Soto trade, has been nothing short of phenomenal for his new club. King has allowed just three earned runs combined across his last four starts and has emerged as a legitimate frontline starter after years in a swingman role with the Yankees.

Fernando Tatis Jr. continues to pace the Padres offensively with eight home runs and 18 RBIs, while offseason acquisition Gavin Sheets has contributed four homers and 14 RBIs. Veterans Machado and Bogaerts have heated up recently, with Machado scoring in four consecutive games and Bogaerts driving in runs in seven of his last eight contests against AL East opponents with winning records.

New York Yankees Analysis: Bronx Bombers Seeking to Snap Slump

The Yankees’ early-season momentum has stalled in recent weeks. Monday’s defeat marked their fourth loss in five games, following disappointing series against division rivals Tampa Bay and Baltimore. Despite the slide, New York’s 19-16 record still has them clinging to first place in the competitive AL East.

Monday’s loss followed a frustrating pattern for the Yankees, as they received excellent starting pitching from Carlos Rodon (6 IP, 0 ER) only to see their bullpen implode in the eighth inning. The relief corps, typically a strength in the Bronx, has shown concerning vulnerability lately.

New York’s pitching has generally been strong this season, posting a solid 3.64 ERA with a 1.20 WHIP and holding opponents to a .204 batting average. Meanwhile, the offense has been more productive than San Diego’s, generating 190 runs with a .260 batting average and .344 on-base percentage.

Clarke Schmidt (0-1, 5.52 ERA, 1.43 WHIP) makes just his third start of the season after beginning the year on the injured list. The right-hander has struggled to find consistency since returning, allowing multiple runs in both outings while failing to pitch beyond the fifth inning.

Superstar Aaron Judge leads the Yankees with 11 home runs and 33 RBIs, continuing to establish himself as baseball’s premier power threat. The surprising development has been Trent Grisham’s emergence, as the defensive specialist has contributed nine homers and 17 RBIs, including a two-run blast in Monday’s loss.

🏆 Get more picks like this every day — join our Telegram and don’t miss out. 💸

Key Betting Trends to Consider

When evaluating this matchup, several notable trends emerge that could influence betting decisions:

Favoring the Yankees:

• Underdogs have won each of the last three meetings between these teams

• The Padres are just 3-7 in their last 10 games as road favorites against American League opponents

• New York has covered the run line in an impressive 18 of their last 22 games when listed as underdogs after playing the previous day

• The Yankees have led after five innings in eight of their last 10 home games against National League opponents

Favoring the Padres:

• San Diego has won six consecutive games overall

• Michael King has been substantially more effective than Clarke Schmidt this season

• The Padres’ pitching staff ranks among MLB’s elite in virtually every category

• Manny Machado has scored in four straight games, suggesting an offensive groove

Total Runs Considerations:

• Eight of San Diego’s last nine games against American League teams have finished UNDER the total

• Seven of New York’s last eight interleague contests have gone OVER the total

• The first inning has been scoreless in each of the Padres’ last four games as favorites against AL East teams

• Conversely, the Yankees have scored or allowed runs in the first inning in each of their last four games as underdogs

Player Props Worth Targeting

Several player-specific trends stand out when analyzing this matchup:

Yankees Players to Watch:

• Trent Grisham has homered in three of his last four night games against NL West teams with winning records

• Jazz Chisholm has crossed the plate in seven of his last eight home appearances

• DJ LeMahieu has recorded at least one single in five consecutive games

Padres Players to Consider:

• Fernando Tatis Jr. has homered in each of San Diego’s last two games as favorites against the Yankees

• Jackson Merrill has doubled in four of his last five road games against winning AL East opponents

• Jake Cronenworth has hit safely in eight straight night games against winning AL East teams

Final Padres vs Yankees Prediction

While conventional wisdom might favor the struggling home team getting plus money, the pitching matchup creates a significant edge for San Diego. Michael King has been among the most effective starters in baseball this season, while Clarke Schmidt continues working through early-season inconsistency following his IL stint.

The Padres’ six-game winning streak demonstrates their current form, and their late-inning comeback in the series opener showcased their resilience. Though the Yankees typically perform well as home underdogs, they’re facing one of the league’s hottest teams with their fifth starter on the mound.

San Diego’s superior pitching staff (2.73 ERA vs. New York’s 3.64) should be the difference-maker in this contest. With King looking to make a statement against his former team and the Padres’ offense coming alive lately, expect San Diego to secure another victory.

Prediction: Padres win 5-2, covering the run line, with the total staying UNDER.

Expert Insights

Is Michael King’s success sustainable as a full-time starter?

Absolutely. King’s transition from swingman to frontline starter has been remarkable. His sinker-sweeper combination has always been elite, but improved command and a more consistent changeup have elevated his game to another level. The Yankees may regret including him in the Juan Soto trade.

What’s behind the Yankees’ recent struggles?

New York’s recent slide stems primarily from bullpen inconsistency and situational hitting failures. They’ve actually outscored opponents during this rough patch but have struggled in high-leverage moments. Look for manager Aaron Boone to shuffle relief roles until stability returns.

Should bettors be concerned about San Diego’s dramatic comeback affecting their energy level?

No. Championship-caliber teams feed off emotional victories rather than experiencing letdowns. The Padres’ veteran leadership (Machado, Bogaerts) ensures they’ll maintain focus throughout this important road trip.

Is the total runs under a strong play given San Diego’s pitching dominance?

Yes. With King’s excellence and the Padres’ overall pitching prowess (eight of their last nine interleague games have gone under), there’s significant value on the under. Schmidt’s inconsistency creates some risk, but Yankee Stadium’s dimensions should contain any damage.

🏆 Want more daily free picks like this? 💸Join our exclusive Telegram channel where we break down NBA and MLB matchups, share real-time betting insights, and help you stay one step ahead 👉 Click here to join!