Mets vs Cardinals: Expert Prediction and Betting Analysis for Sunday’s MLB Doubleheader

Cardinals Look to Rebound After Disappointing Series Opener

The St. Louis Cardinals (14-19) find themselves in a challenging position heading into Sunday’s doubleheader against the New York Mets at Busch Stadium. After dropping Friday’s opener 9-3, the Cardinals need to capitalize on their strong 10-6 home record to avoid falling further behind in the competitive NL Central race.

Friday’s contest revealed the Cardinals’ ongoing struggles, as they jumped to early leads (1-0 in the first and 3-2 in the third) but failed to produce any offense in the final six innings. Masyn Winn and Willson Contreras provided the only run production, with one RBI each. Starting pitcher Sonny Gray labored through 4.1 innings, surrendering nine hits and four earned runs before the bullpen allowed additional damage.

St. Louis enters this doubleheader having lost four of their last six games, placing them fourth in the NL Central standings. Their pitching staff carries a concerning 4.31 ERA with a 1.26 WHIP and .244 opponent batting average. The offense has generated 150 runs with a .256 batting average and .329 on-base percentage this season.

Mets Aim to Continue Hot Start Behind Balanced Attack

The New York Mets (22-11) continue to impress in 2025, leading the NL East after Friday’s convincing 9-3 victory over the Cardinals. The Mets demonstrated their offensive firepower with 17 hits, including a standout performance from Francisco Alvarez, who went 3-5 with three RBIs.

New York’s pitching has been exceptional, carrying a stellar 2.69 ERA with a 1.22 WHIP and .231 opponent batting average. Grant Holmes earned the win on Friday, allowing three earned runs over six innings before the bullpen closed the door with three scoreless frames.

Despite their overall success, the Mets have been more vulnerable on the road (9-8) compared to their dominant home performance. They’ve split their last six games overall but have shown resilience against NL Central competition, winning six straight against the division.

Pitching Matchup Analysis: Experience vs. Potential

Game One: Blake Tidwell (NYM) vs. Erick Fedde (STL)

Game one features an intriguing pitching matchup with Blake Tidwell making his MLB debut for the Mets against the Cardinals’ Erick Fedde (1-3, 4.68 ERA, 1.35 WHIP). Fedde has struggled with consistency this season but has shown an ability to generate strikeouts, recording four or more Ks in five of his last six home appearances against NL East teams with winning records.

The rookie Tidwell represents a wild card in this matchup. Without major league experience, the Cardinals hitters will be facing him for the first time, which often benefits the pitcher initially. However, Tidwell will be tested by a Cardinals lineup that has shown they can manufacture early runs, having scored in the first inning in each of their last six games as underdogs against National League opponents.

Game Two: Tylor Megill (NYM) vs. Andre Pallante (STL)

The nightcap features a more established pitching matchup with Tylor Megill (3-2, 1.74 ERA, 1.13 WHIP) taking the mound for New York against St. Louis’ Andre Pallante (2-2, 4.13 ERA, 1.29 WHIP). Megill has been one of the pleasant surprises for the Mets this season, demonstrating excellent command and limiting opposing hitters effectively.

Pallante has shown flashes of potential for the Cardinals but hasn’t matched Megill’s consistency. His ability to limit the powerful Mets lineup—particularly Pete Alonso, who has homered in four of the Mets’ last five games at Busch Stadium against struggling NL Central teams—will be crucial to the Cardinals’ chances in game two.

🏆 Get more picks like this every day — join our Telegram and don’t miss out. 💸

Key Betting Trends and Player Props to Consider

Several compelling trends stand out for this doubleheader:

• St. Louis home advantage: The Cardinals have covered the run line in seven of their last eight day games following a home loss, suggesting they could bounce back in game one.

• Mets road dominance against St. Louis: New York has covered the run line in seven of their last eight games at Busch Stadium, indicating confidence playing in this venue.

• Total runs tendencies: Five of the Cardinals’ last six home games against NL East opponents have gone UNDER the total, while four of the Mets’ last five games as favorites against National League opponents have gone OVER.

Player prop opportunities abound in this matchup:

• Willson Contreras has hit home runs in three of his last six home appearances against NL East opponents

• Masyn Winn has scored at least one run in seven straight home games against winning NL teams

• Pete Alonso has scored in eight of the Mets’ last nine road games

• Jeff McNeil has recorded hits in eight consecutive games at Busch Stadium

Final Prediction: Expect a Split Doubleheader with Contrasting Styles

After analyzing all factors, I’m predicting a split doubleheader. Game one should feature significant offensive production from both teams, with the Cardinals’ home field advantage and strong record as home underdogs after a loss giving them the edge in a high-scoring affair. Look for first-inning scoring and Willson Contreras to make an impact with an RBI.

For game two, Tylor Megill’s impressive 1.74 ERA should prove too much for the struggling Cardinals offense. The Mets’ strong record against NL Central opponents, combined with Pete Alonso’s success at Busch Stadium, makes New York -1.5 the recommended play for the nightcap.

Expert Insights

Why is Tylor Megill having such success this season?

Megill has refined his pitch mix in 2025, increasing his slider usage while maintaining exceptional command. His 1.13 WHIP demonstrates his ability to keep runners off base, and he’s been particularly effective against right-handed hitters, holding them to a sub-.200 batting average.

Can the Cardinals turn around their season after a disappointing start?

St. Louis has the talent to improve, particularly if their veteran core of Goldschmidt, Arenado, and Contreras can find consistency. Their 10-6 home record suggests they perform significantly better at Busch Stadium, giving them a foundation to build upon as they attempt to climb back into NL Central contention.

Which player props offer the best value for this doubleheader?

Look for Masyn Winn to record a hit and score a run in game one – he’s been remarkably consistent at home against quality NL competition. For New York, Brandon Nimmo’s RBI streak against losing teams makes him an attractive option, especially given the Cardinals’ pitching struggles.

How important is this doubleheader for both teams’ seasons?

For the Cardinals, these games represent a critical opportunity to gain momentum before they fall too far behind in the division race. For the Mets, maintaining their strong start and road performance will be essential as they look to build cushion in the competitive NL East.

Should bettors focus more on trends or current form when analyzing this matchup?

The confluence of the Mets’ dominant pitching (2.69 ERA) and the Cardinals’ home success (10-6) makes this an interesting handicapping challenge. For game one with two questionable starters, recent offensive trends suggest the OVER. For game two, Megill’s current form trumps historical trends, making the Mets -1.5 the more confident play.

🏆 Want more daily free picks like this? 💸

Join our exclusive Telegram channel where we break down NBA and MLB matchups, share real-time betting insights, and help you stay one step ahead 👉 Click here to join!