Diamondbacks vs Cardinals expert prediction, picks & odds

The Arizona Diamondbacks (26-25, 4th in NL West) face a pivotal moment as they host the St. Louis Cardinals (28-23, 2nd in NL Central) in Sunday’s series finale at Chase Field. This afternoon showdown carries significant implications for both franchises, with Arizona desperately seeking to salvage the final contest after dropping the series opener. The desert squad will rely on right-hander Brandon Pfaadt (7-3, 3.81 ERA) making his 11th appearance, while St. Louis counters with veteran southpaw Sonny Gray (5-1, 4.02 ERA) in what promises to be a compelling pitching duel.

The Cardinals enter with momentum after capturing Friday’s series opener, extending their recent dominance over Arizona that dates back to their previous three-game sweep in St. Louis last season. Sunday’s 2:15 PM Eastern first pitch sets the stage for what could be a season-defining moment for the struggling Diamondbacks.

Arizona’s Offensive Struggles Continue to Mount

The Diamondbacks find themselves mired in their most challenging stretch of the season, having suffered three consecutive defeats that highlight their concerning offensive inconsistencies. Friday’s 4-3 setback against St. Louis perfectly encapsulated Arizona’s current predicament, as their lineup managed just enough production to stay competitive but ultimately fell short when it mattered most.

Ketel Marte and Gabriel Moreno provided the offensive highlights with solo home runs, but the supporting cast failed to capitalize on crucial scoring opportunities. This pattern has become alarmingly familiar for Arizona, as they’ve managed three runs or fewer in four of their last five contests. The statistical evidence paints a troubling picture: the Diamondbacks are averaging just 3.8 runs per game during this recent slide, well below their season average of 4.6 runs.

Starting pitcher Zac Gallen absorbed his sixth loss despite a respectable effort, surrendering four earned runs across 5.2 innings. While Arizona’s bullpen performed admirably in relief, shutting down St. Louis completely after Gallen’s departure, the damage had already been inflicted during the middle innings when the Cardinals seized control.

Brandon Pfaadt’s Redemption Opportunity

Pfaadt enters Sunday’s assignment carrying both promise and concern based on his historical performance against St. Louis. The right-hander’s career numbers versus the Cardinals present a mixed narrative: 0-0 record accompanied by an elevated 6.35 ERA across 11.1 innings of work. His most recent encounter with St. Louis occurred last season at Busch Stadium, where he delivered a solid 5.1-inning performance, limiting the Cardinals to two earned runs while striking out four batters.

The 25-year-old’s overall season statistics suggest significant improvement from his previous campaign, with his 3.81 ERA representing a marked enhancement in consistency and command. Pfaadt’s strikeout rate has climbed to 8.7 per nine innings, indicating improved swing-and-miss stuff that should serve him well against a Cardinals lineup that has shown vulnerability to quality breaking balls.

Arizona’s recent defensive struggles have compounded their pitching staff’s challenges, as they’ve surrendered four or more runs in three of their previous four games. Pfaadt’s ability to limit hard contact and induce ground balls will be crucial in preventing the Cardinals from building upon their recent offensive momentum.

Cardinals Riding Wave of Timely Hitting

St. Louis snapped their brief two-game losing streak with Friday’s victory, showcasing the clutch hitting that has defined their successful 2025 campaign thus far. The Cardinals’ sixth-inning explosion perfectly demonstrated their ability to capitalize on scoring opportunities, with Nolan Arenado‘s bases-loaded triple serving as the decisive blow that broke the game open.

Miles Mikolas earned his fourth victory by delivering exactly what the Cardinals needed: six innings of controlled pitching that kept Arizona’s offense at bay. The veteran right-hander’s performance highlighted St. Louis’s depth and reliability in their starting rotation, factors that have contributed significantly to their current positioning atop the competitive NL Central standings.

Victory Scott II’s two-run performance exemplified the Cardinals’ balanced offensive approach, with contributions coming from throughout their lineup rather than relying solely on their established stars. This depth has proven invaluable during their recent stretch, though they’ve also shown some inconsistency by failing to exceed four runs in five of their last six contests.

🏆 Get more picks like this every day — join our Telegram and don’t miss out. 💸

Sonny Gray’s Veteran Presence

The 35-year-old Gray brings extensive experience and a track record of success against NL West opponents to Sunday’s crucial assignment. His limited history against Arizona includes one previous encounter while pitching for Oakland, where he delivered 6.1 strong innings and allowed just two earned runs at Chase Field.

Gray’s 2025 performance has exceeded expectations, particularly his ability to limit hard contact and generate weak contact through his diverse pitch mix. His 4.02 ERA slightly understates his actual effectiveness, as advanced metrics suggest he’s been somewhat unlucky with balls in play and strand rate. The veteran’s experience in high-leverage situations should prove valuable in what promises to be a tightly contested finale.

St. Louis’s pitching staff has shown some vulnerability recently, surrendering four or more runs in three of their previous four games. However, Gray’s track record suggests he’s capable of bucking this trend, particularly given his success rate in series-deciding games throughout his distinguished career.

Weather and Venue Factors

Chase Field’s controlled environment eliminates weather variables, but the venue’s notorious hitter-friendly dimensions could favor both offenses in Sunday’s finale. The stadium’s low altitude and favorable hitting background have historically produced elevated offensive numbers, particularly during afternoon games when lighting conditions are optimal.

Arizona’s home field advantage becomes particularly relevant given their recent struggles on the road. The Diamondbacks have compiled a respectable 15-11 record at Chase Field this season, compared to their disappointing 11-14 mark in away contests. This home/road split suggests the familiar surroundings could provide the spark needed to break their current losing streak.

Key Insights

Will Brandon Pfaadt bounce back against a Cardinals lineup that previously troubled him?

Pfaadt’s improved command and enhanced strikeout rate suggest he’s better equipped to handle St. Louis this time around. His 3.81 ERA represents significant growth from last season, and his recent ability to limit walks should help him navigate the Cardinals’ patient approach at the plate.

Can Arizona’s offense finally break through against quality pitching?

The Diamondbacks’ recent struggles stem primarily from their inability to capitalize with runners in scoring position. Marte and Moreno have provided consistent power, but the supporting cast must contribute more consistent production to overcome their current offensive drought.

How will Sonny Gray handle the pressure of a series-deciding game?

Gray’s veteran experience in crucial situations gives him a significant advantage. His career record in series finales and high-leverage games suggests he thrives under pressure, making him an ideal choice for St. Louis in this spot.

What role will the bullpens play in determining the outcome?

Both teams have shown recent bullpen effectiveness, with Arizona’s relief corps shutting down opponents after struggling starts. The Cardinals’ bullpen depth could prove decisive if Gray struggles early or if the game extends into extra innings.

Is this a must-win game for Arizona’s playoff aspirations?

While still early in the season, continued losses could create a significant deficit for the Diamondbacks in the competitive NL West. A victory would provide crucial momentum heading into a challenging upcoming road series.

Final Prediction and Analysis

The Cardinals enter as slight favorites based on their superior overall record and recent head-to-head success against Arizona. Gray’s experience and the Cardinals’ timely hitting give them the edge in what should be a closely contested finale. However, Pfaadt’s improvement and Arizona’s desperation for a home victory create compelling reasons to consider an upset.

Final Score Prediction: Cardinals 6, Diamondbacks 4 Total Runs Prediction: Over 9.5 

Win Probabilities: Cardinals 58%, Diamondbacks 42%

🏆 Want more daily free picks like this? 💸Join our exclusive Telegram channel where we break down NBA and MLB matchups, share real-time betting insights, and help you stay one step ahead 👉 Click here to join!