05/19/25 Diamondbacks vs Dodgers: MLB Expert betting analysis and predictions

Diamondbacks vs Dodgers expert prediction, picks & odds

The Arizona Diamondbacks head to Southern California for a critical NL West showdown against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium. With Brandon Pfaadt on the mound for Arizona facing Los Angeles’ emerging talent Landon Knack, this matchup presents intriguing betting opportunities. First pitch is scheduled for 10:10 PM EST on Sunday, and our comprehensive analysis will provide you with expert insights to inform your wagers on this divisional clash.

Pitching Matchup: Pfaadt vs. Knack Analysis

The pitching duel in this contest features contrasting narratives – a developing starter finding his footing against a rookie trying to establish consistency at the major league level.

Brandon Pfaadt enters this start with a respectable 6-3 record and 3.73 ERA across nine starts in 2025. The right-hander has demonstrated improved command compared to his rookie campaign, posting a solid 44:13 strikeout-to-walk ratio over approximately 50 innings pitched. However, his most recent outing against the Giants revealed some vulnerability, lasting just four innings while surrendering six hits and four earned runs in a losing effort.

A concerning metric for Arizona supporters is the .266 opponent batting average against Pfaadt, suggesting contact quality has been problematic. His 1.30 WHIP indicates baserunner management has been an ongoing challenge, particularly against left-handed hitters who have posted a .289 average against him this season. Pfaadt’s performance at Dodger Stadium has historically been problematic – in three career starts at this venue, he’s posted a 6.17 ERA with four home runs allowed across 15.2 innings.

For the Dodgers, Landon Knack represents their latest pitching development project thrust into significant innings due to rotation injuries. The 26-year-old right-hander has shown electric stuff but inconsistent results, evidenced by his 5.89 ERA and 1.53 WHIP across five appearances (four starts). His most recent outing against Oakland was particularly troubling, as he surrendered five earned runs across 4.2 innings despite recording eight strikeouts.

Knack’s raw ability is undeniable – his 20 strikeouts across 18.1 innings translates to a promising 9.8 K/9 rate – but command issues have prevented longer outings, with only one start exceeding five innings this season. The .274 opponent batting average highlights the development still needed to consistently retire major league hitters.

Recent Team Performance Trends

The Diamondbacks entered their Colorado series demonstrating offensive potency but pitching inconsistency. Their 8-0 victory in the series opener showcased their ceiling, while the subsequent 14-12 slugfest loss illustrated their vulnerability in high-scoring affairs. Arizona has scored at least five runs in seven of their last ten games, maintaining a team OPS of .752 over that span – seventh-best in baseball during this period.

Ketel Marte and Corbin Carroll have been catalysts for the Arizona offense, with Marte’s .888 OPS pacing the team and Carroll’s 17 stolen bases creating consistent scoring opportunities. Christian Walker has provided middle-order power with 13 home runs, though his .232 batting average suggests some boom-or-bust tendencies.

The Dodgers, meanwhile, entered their Freeway Series against the Angels in an uncharacteristic slump, dropping both opening games by scores of 6-2 and 11-9. Their typically reliable pitching staff has surrendered 5+ runs in six consecutive contests – a shocking development for a franchise known for pitching excellence. However, Los Angeles still boasts the third-highest run differential in the National League at +47, suggesting their fundamental performance remains strong despite recent struggles.

Shohei Ohtani continues his MVP-caliber campaign with a .321/.401/.598 slash line, while Mookie Betts (.923 OPS) and Freddie Freeman (.882 OPS) provide the lineup depth that makes Los Angeles so formidable. The Dodgers’ 78 home runs lead the National League, creating a significant power advantage in most matchups.

🏆 Get more picks like this every day — join our Telegram and don’t miss out. 💸

Ballpark Factors and Weather Considerations

Dodger Stadium has played closer to neutral in 2025 after years as a pitcher-friendly venue, ranking 13th in MLB for run-scoring environment. The mild May temperatures in Los Angeles typically favor pitchers, with evening games seeing reduced carry compared to day contests. Sunday’s forecast calls for temperatures around 68°F at first pitch with minimal wind impact, creating standard conditions for this matchup.

Both teams have contrasting historical performances at this venue – the Dodgers are 17-7 at home this season, while Arizona has struggled to a 9-14 road record. In head-to-head meetings at Dodger Stadium since 2023, Los Angeles holds a commanding 14-5 advantage, underscoring their territorial dominance.

Betting Trends and Value Analysis

The betting market opened with Los Angeles as -165 home favorites with the total set at 9 runs. Early movement has pushed the line toward -170 and the total up to 9.5, suggesting professional money favors the Dodgers and the over.

Several trends support this market direction:

  • The Dodgers are 23-9 in their last 32 home games against right-handed starters
  • Arizona is 3-7 in their last 10 road games against teams with winning records
  • The OVER is 8-2 in the last 10 meetings between these teams at Dodger Stadium
  • The Dodgers are 16-5 in their last 21 divisional home games

The run line (-1.5) sits at approximately +125 for Los Angeles, presenting intriguing value given the offensive firepower in their lineup and Arizona’s bullpen inconsistency (4.78 ERA, 24th in MLB).

Final Prediction and Best Bets

While recent form suggests vulnerability for both starting pitchers, Los Angeles holds significant advantages in home performance, bullpen depth, and offensive consistency. Pfaadt’s historical struggles at Dodger Stadium combined with Knack’s swing-and-miss potential create a scenario where the Dodgers should prevail in a higher-scoring affair.

Our projection model indicates a 6-4 Los Angeles victory, with both starters likely exiting before completing six innings. The strongest value appears to be on the Dodgers’ run line (-1.5, +125) and the over 9.5 runs, particularly if you can find the total at 9 with reduced juice.

Score Prediction: Los Angeles Dodgers 6, Arizona Diamondbacks 4

Best Bet: Dodgers -1.5 (+125)

Total Recommendation: OVER 9.5 runs (-105)

Expert Insights

Is Brandon Pfaadt’s 3.73 ERA sustainable given his peripheral metrics?

The underlying numbers suggest regression is likely. Pfaadt’s .266 opponent batting average and 1.30 WHIP indicate he’s allowing too much traffic on the basepaths for his ERA to remain below 4.00 long-term. His 44:13 K/BB ratio is solid but not elite, and his 1.4 HR/9 rate suggests vulnerability against power-hitting lineups like the Dodgers.

What’s behind Landon Knack’s struggles despite his impressive strikeout numbers?

Knack’s issues stem primarily from inefficiency and third-time-through-the-order penalties. He’s averaging just 4.2 innings per start while throwing 18.3 pitches per inning – significantly higher than the league average of 16.4. His first-pitch strike percentage of 57% (league average: 61%) puts him behind in counts too frequently, creating predictable fastball counts that major league hitters exploit.

How does the Diamondbacks’ offensive approach match up against Dodger Stadium?

Arizona’s offense is built around speed and gap power, with their 53 stolen bases ranking second in the National League. While Dodger Stadium suppresses some extra-base hits, its spacious outfield creates opportunities for Arizona’s athletic lineup to take extra bases. Look for Corbin Carroll and Geraldo Perdomo to be particularly aggressive on the basepaths against Dodgers catcher Will Smith, who has thrown out just 21% of attempted base stealers this season.

What’s the key matchup that could decide this game?

The most critical confrontation will be the Diamondbacks’ middle relievers against the Dodgers’ 4-5-6 hitters. With both starters likely exiting before the sixth inning, Arizona’s vulnerable middle relief corps (5.32 ERA from innings 6-8) will face Los Angeles’ most dangerous lineup segment. If Arizona manager Torey Lovullo can navigate this high-leverage sequence without significant damage, the Diamondbacks have upset potential with closer Paul Sewald’s effectiveness in the ninth inning.

How important is this divisional matchup in the NL West race?

With both teams separated by just 3.5 games in the division standings, this series carries significant implications beyond single-game outcomes. The psychological advantage gained from winning divisional series has proven meaningful in recent NL West races, with the 2024 season seeing the division decided by just two games. A Diamondbacks series victory would signal legitimate contention status, while a Dodgers sweep would create early separation in the standings.

🏆 Want more daily free picks like this? 💸Join our exclusive Telegram channel where we break down NBA and MLB matchups, share real-time betting insights, and help you stay one step ahead 👉 Click here to join!