MLB Betting Preview: Chicago White Sox vs. Cincinnati Reds

Thursday’s matinee action concludes an intriguing three-game series at Great American Ball Park as the Cincinnati Reds host the Chicago White Sox. This midday clash (12:40 PM ET) offers compelling betting angles despite featuring two teams struggling to find consistency in the early portion of the 2025 campaign. Our comprehensive betting preview delivers expert analysis, valuable insights, and a high-confidence prediction to help you find the edge in this National League versus American League matchup.

White Sox Finding Their Footing in May Despite Overall Struggles

The Chicago White Sox (13-29) have endured a brutal start to their 2025 campaign, firmly entrenched at the bottom of the AL Central standings. However, a closer examination reveals a team showing modest signs of life in recent weeks. Their extra-innings victory in Tuesday’s series opener demonstrated resilience not previously seen from this squad, and they’ve now claimed three wins in their previous four contests heading into Wednesday’s matchup.

May has brought a markedly improved pitching performance from Chicago, with a team ERA of 3.57 this month compared to an alarming 4.74 in April. This dramatic improvement explains why the White Sox have managed to compile a respectable .500 record in May despite their overall losing record. The pitching staff has been particularly stingy lately, surrendering more than four runs just once in their past 10 outings.

Tuesday’s series opener showcased this improved formula, as Jonathan Cannon delivered six scoreless frames before Chicago’s bullpen faltered. The offense eventually came through when it mattered most, with Chase Meidreth‘s clutch RBI single in the 10th inning followed by Miguel Vargas’ decisive three-run blast. Vargas has emerged as a rare bright spot in an otherwise anemic lineup, posting a team-leading .896 OPS over the past two weeks with multiple home runs and extra-base hits.

Bryse Wilson Gets the Nod for Chicago

Right-hander Bryse Wilson takes the mound for Chicago on Thursday, making his fourth start of the 2025 season after primarily working from the bullpen. Wilson has compiled an 0-1 record with a 4.88 ERA across 13 appearances, striking out 16 batters through 27.2 innings of work.

His most recent performance offered legitimate encouragement for White Sox backers, as Wilson limited the Marlins to just three hits and one run over five effective innings. The 27-year-old has been gradually building arm strength since transitioning from relief duties, and Thursday represents an opportunity to build on his best start of the season.

Wilson’s primary challenge has been maintaining effectiveness beyond the first time through an opposing lineup. Opponents are batting just .216 against him in their first plate appearance but that figure jumps dramatically to .304 in subsequent at-bats. Manager Pedro Grifol will likely have a quick hook ready if Wilson shows signs of fatigue as he approaches the middle innings.

Reds’ Offensive Struggles Threaten Playoff Aspirations

The Cincinnati Reds (20-23) entered 2025 with heightened expectations following promising development from their young core last season. However, recent offensive woes have caused a significant slide in the standings, with Tuesday’s defeat marking their eighth loss in ten games. Cincinnati’s anemic attack has produced just a .632 OPS in May, ranking 14th among 15 National League teams and ahead of only division rival Pittsburgh.

Injury issues have compounded Cincinnati’s problems at the plate. The team was already navigating absences from key contributors like Noelvi Marte, Jake Fraley, and Jeimer Candelario when they suffered another potential blow on Tuesday. Outfielder TJ Friedl exited after colliding with shortstop Elly De La Cruz in the outfield, resulting in a wrist injury that required an MRI. His day-to-day status adds another layer of uncertainty to an already depleted lineup.

De La Cruz’s late solo home run Tuesday represented Cincinnati’s only offensive highlight, as the team was shut out through eight innings before his blast. Even more concerning for Reds backers was the team’s inability to produce anything in the 10th inning despite starting with a runner on second base per extra-innings rules.

🏆 Get more picks like this every day — join our Telegram and don’t miss out. 💸

Nick Martinez Seeks Run Support

Right-hander Nick Martinez draws the assignment for Cincinnati on Thursday, following southpaws Andrew Abbott and Nick Lodolo in the rotation this series. Martinez has compiled a 1-4 record across eight starts in 2025, posting a respectable 4.23 ERA despite minimal offensive backing.

His most recent outing encapsulated Cincinnati’s offensive struggles perfectly – Martinez delivered a quality start by allowing three runs across six innings against Houston while striking out five, but received zero run support in a 3-0 defeat. The veteran right-hander has now received just seven total runs of support across his past four starts.

Martinez has traditionally performed well at Great American Ball Park despite its hitter-friendly reputation, registering a 3.76 ERA across 38.1 innings at the venue. His ability to mix five different pitches effectively has helped him navigate Cincinnati’s challenging home environment.

Statistical Breakdown: Pitching Edge Emerges in Struggling Offenses

When analyzing this matchup statistically, several key trends emerge that provide betting value:

• Chicago’s team ERA in May (3.57) ranks among the top 10 in baseball during this span

• The White Sox have played to the Under in 7 of their last 9 road games

• Cincinnati games have gone Under the total in 8 of their past 12 contests

• The Reds rank 26th in MLB in runs scored over the past two weeks (3.64 per game)

• Chicago ranks dead last in baseball in runs per game (3.29) for the season

The Under has hit in four straight meetings between these teams dating back to last season, with an average combined score of just 6.75 runs per game. With both offenses struggling and pitching showing improvement, Thursday’s matinee sets up perfectly for another low-scoring affair.

Prediction and Best Bet for White Sox vs. Reds

After thorough analysis, our prediction leans toward the Cincinnati Reds securing a narrow victory in a low-scoring contest. Both teams have struggled offensively, but the Reds’ slight home-field advantage and Martinez’s success at Great American Ball Park give them a modest edge.

Score Prediction: Cincinnati Reds 4, Chicago White Sox 3

Best Bet: UNDER 8.5 runs (-110)

The Under represents the strongest betting value in this matchup. With both offenses ranking among the worst in baseball recently and the pitching showing marked improvement, expect a methodical, low-scoring series finale. The early start time (12:40 PM ET) provides another advantage for pitchers, as daytime shadows often create additional challenges for hitters, particularly in the early innings.

Betting Insights: Finding Value Beyond the Standard Markets

What makes the Under 8.5 such a strong play in this matchup?

Both teams have demonstrated consistent struggles generating offense, with the White Sox ranking last in baseball in runs scored and the Reds placing 26th over the past two weeks. Additionally, day games at Great American Ball Park have averaged 1.4 fewer runs compared to night games this season, creating perfect conditions for an Under.

Should bettors consider the Reds on the money line despite their recent slide?

While Cincinnati has value as a home favorite, their inconsistent offense makes them difficult to trust laying -140 or more. The total offers better value, though a small play on the Reds could be justified if the line moves closer to -125.

How should Wilson’s limited pitch count impact betting strategy?

Wilson hasn’t thrown more than 75 pitches in any outing this season, which actually strengthens the Under case. Chicago’s bullpen has performed admirably in May with a 3.12 ERA, meaning the White Sox pitching should remain effective even after Wilson exits.

Does the Reds’ injury situation create a potential live betting opportunity?

Absolutely. If Friedl is confirmed out and the Reds field a particularly weak lineup, consider waiting for an early run or two before targeting an even better Under price in-game, potentially at 9.5 or higher.

What alternative bet offers the best secondary value?

Consider a First 5 Innings Under 4.5 (+100) as both starters have been significantly more effective early in games before facing lineups multiple times. This provides a shorter window of exposure and eliminates some bullpen uncertainty.

🏆 Want more daily free picks like this? 💸

Join our exclusive Telegram channel where we break down NBA and MLB matchups, share real-time betting insights, and help you stay one step ahead 👉 Click here to join!